Visit Us
Antonio's Macarons Logo
Antonio's Macarons Logo
  • Home
  • Order Macarons
  • About
  • Blog
  • Contact
845-208-9745
Home/Blog/What to Know Before Ordering a Custom Cake (Size, Flavor & Design)

What to Know Before Ordering a Custom Cake (Size, Flavor & Design)

Faith Otutu
January 19, 2026
Cake
What to Know Before Ordering a Custom Cake (Size, Flavor & Design)


Choosing the Right Cake Size

 

Cake size is one of the most important decisions and depends on your guest count

General guidelines:

  • Small gatherings (6–10 people): Single-tier cake
  • Medium events (15–30 people): Larger single tier or two tiers
  • Large celebrations (40+ people): Multi-tier cake

If you’re unsure, it’s always better to size up — leftover cake is rarely a problem.


Selecting the Perfect Flavor

Flavor matters just as much as appearance.

Tips for choosing flavors:

  • Pick crowd-pleasers if serving many guests
  • Consider lighter flavors for daytime events
  • Rich flavors work well for evening celebrations

Popular choices include vanilla, chocolate, red velvet, lemon, and classic fruit flavors. Some cakes can also include different flavors per tier.


Deciding on the Design

Design brings your cake to life.

Before ordering, think about:

  • Event theme or color palette
  • Preferred style (simple, elegant, modern, or bold)
  • Decorative elements like florals, textures, or patterns

Providing reference photos can help communicate your vision clearly.


Order Timing Matters

Custom cakes require planning.

Helpful tips:

  • Order early, especially for weekends or busy seasons
  • Confirm the event date and pickup or delivery details
  • Finalize details a few days before the event

Planning ahead ensures availability and accuracy.


Communicate Special Requests Clearly

Let your cake designer know about:

  • Allergies or dietary preferences
  • Custom messages or toppers
  • Portion needs for children or mixed audiences

Clear communication avoids last-minute surprises.

Final Slice

A custom cake is more than dessert — it’s a centerpiece. Knowing the right size, choosing flavors your guests will love, and planning a design that fits your event ensures a smooth experience and a cake that makes a statement.

A little preparation goes a long way toward creating something truly special.

Back to Blog

New York Location

Visit us in New Windsor for fresh cupcakes, macarons, and custom cakes made daily.

Antonio's Macarons

113 Temple Hill Rd

New Windsor, NY 12553

Plan Your Visit

Popular Products

  • Build Your Own Macaron Box

    Mix and match your favorite flavors.

  • Custom Cakes

    Designed just for your celebration.

Popular Blog Posts

  • Wedding Cake Tips Every Couple Should Know

    Mar 2, 2026

  • Cupcake vs Cake: Which Should You Choose?

    Mar 1, 2026

  • Top Cupcake Trends Right Now

    Feb 28, 2026

Antonio's Macarons Logo

Antonio's Macarons

113 Temple Hill Rd

New Windsor, NY 12553

hello@antoniosmacarons.com

845-208-9745

Our Hours

8:00AM - 8:00PM Daily

Membership

Antonio’s is a home for creative people to meet, come together and belong. Our bakery is home to a macaron factory and is open for delivery to local customers and for members who need a place to work, play and meet.

Learn More →

Sweet Updates

Get the latest news on fresh treats, seasonal specials, and exclusive offers delivered to your inbox!

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time. By subscribing, you agree to receive marketing emails from Antonio's Macarons.

About UsMembershipPrivacy PolicyReturns PolicyFAQ
© 2023 Antonio's Macarons LLC. All rights reserved.
Made with ♥ in New Windsor, NY